Jimin Jibao

Home / JJ Podcast / Episode 16

Closing line value. Why I don’t trust it.

Everybody talks about CLV and +EV now. In the markets I bet, a closing line that moved your way doesn’t have to mean anything. Somebody betting big can move a line everywhere, and it can be information or just an opinion. JJ Podcast, episode 16. The full transcript is under the video.

17:59. Also on YouTube ↗. The voice is a masked voice, on purpose.

In this episode

The transcript

I want to admit one thing, I’m betting for 20 plus years, and it was just only recently, last month, after I started this online Jimin Jibao project, that I learned the following English terms, which are very very popular now. I think it’s PLUS EV and CLV, something like that. These things are very popular now, and every influencer that respects himself has to write something about it, make some program or whatever.

As far as I understand, and I can be wrong, because I just remember this, I’m driving right now, and honestly, I didn’t check before recording this, what those things are, but I think it’s CLV is like closing line value, or whatever, I think it’s the idea is that you judge your bets against the closing line, and so you take your bets early, and then if they, if when the line closes, you took better odds.

And this is considered very good. I mean, this, in theory, it should work, right, and, but honestly, I never ever judge my bets or some other bets by this value, because, and what I bet, and again, when I’m talking about this, I only talk about the things I bet, the markets I bet, which are lower league basketball.

I don’t bet NBA, I don’t bet Euroleague, I don’t bet Spain, so on and so on, so I’m talking about lower league basketball, and in these markets, I seriously don’t look at this closing line. It has some merit, but the point is, it doesn’t have to represent anything. It can, but it doesn’t, doesn’t have to.

And there are examples every day, that, that this line, this value is, I don’t know, it’s, it’s connected to the whole line movement idea, yes, and I’ve recorded some stuff on that also, and some articles on my site, and I just, I just don’t buy into that. You know, why I don’t buy into it, because I’ve, I’ve seen so many times when this closing line, or the line movement, it don’t mean anything.

Unfortunately, unfortunately, as I said before, I’m a human being, and psychologically this stuff works on me, what it does, it plants doubt. In my previous podcast about this, I spoke about the match where everything pointed one way, and the line was moving the other way, and we still, my team was still bad. The thing we thought was good, which was backed by facts, players missing, players returning, so on and so on. And we won, but the line movement planted doubt, and I should have taken more on that.

So, today, and I’m talking about November 11th, I don’t know when this podcast will be released, but today, I’ve seen, there have been like some line movements like that, where the closing value was very, very different from what it was before, and in the end it didn’t represent anything. I mean, okay, there was a game in Japan, Akita versus Ibaraki, and Ibaraki was missing its best player, Vic Law, and the line moved from like, from money line on Akita for like 3.5 or something, to like 1.6 or something.

That’s a huge move. And that’s Japan. That market is very big. You can bet like thousands of euros on the money line, on Pinnacle, and that’s where the line was moving. Okay, the line was moving because the player was missing. Right. I, I, let’s say, I agree with the direction of the movement. Yes. But I would never agree with the, with the amount it moved by in the end, and it was too big, and I didn’t consider betting on Akita. And the line movement was so big that the smart thing would be to bet on Ibaraki, but I didn’t, I didn’t react to it.

But, uh, I think that sometimes, most of the times, it’s better to ignore stuff than to chase. And, uh, what was happening, uh, Akita was winning the whole game, and it looked easy, right, and correct. But then the last, the last quarter they lost by 20 or something, and they lost the match by about 10, I think.

So, this line movement, okay, this time it represented the real information, but it still was too much. And, uh, that’s why I don’t like it. That’s why when it’s too much, you should consider, everybody should consider betting in opposite. Uh, but, uh, of course, team news have, have, have to be studied, uh, very carefully. There was a second game, and that one, uh, that game was so funny in a sense that that one game taught us so many lessons. I already have on the site an article about, uh, how you can’t, uh, trust the official box scores.

Uh, that game was in, uh, uh, East Asia Super League. That’s, uh, let’s call it private league, uh, one of the new ones. But, uh, it, uh, it, it was valued at over 100 million dollars. And, uh, it has, like, backing from NBA stars, tens of thousands, tens of millions of dollars in capital, so on and so on. Uh, and their box score, the official box score on their site had, like, two huge, uh, errors. And I have that article on my site.

Uh, what happened was, uh, uh, the box score didn’t count technical fouls in the total fouls for a player. So, one player stayed, uh, on four fouls, even though he fell out in, in the beginning of the fourth quarter. And the other player had, uh, actually four fouls in the very first quarter. And the box score had three. And it still had three in the, in the end.

And, uh, that player who fell out, actually, uh, let me go back a little bit. What happened before the game is, uh, the initial odds were minus, about minus 5.5 on the home team, uh, Korean team, KCC. Uh, they played against the Taiwan team, uh, uh, Fubon Braves. So, initial line was about minus 5.5. And, uh, towards the game, the game actually closed at, uh, like, uh, KCC money line 1.8 or something.

Maybe a little less. But still it was like minus 1.5 maximum. So, the line moved like four points towards Fubon. And normally, okay, uh, like in our previous example, you would think, okay, there has to be some, uh, big news here. And, uh, we spotted this and we thought, okay, let’s wait, uh, we, uh, uh, checked everything. We couldn’t find any news, but, uh, uh, we assumed that somebody should be missing. Right? There were, there are two Americans on the team.

So, maybe one of them is missing to, to justify that move. But the game started and nobody was missing for KCC. And, uh, uh, Fubon is a normal lineup. There was nothing, nothing, uh, changing there in the last moments. So, the line move was not justified by anything. Right? Then the, then the thing happened, uh, uh, one of the home team, uh, players got, uh, four fouls. In the first quarter, not one of the, one of the Americans, the only big man they have.

And, uh, we already had analysis on that game. And it was a logical thing to do, to bet on the Taiwanese team. Right? And, uh, after we batted, they started just dominating. Because, uh, uh, if, uh, center gets four fouls in the first quarter, he sits down. At least, uh, until after halftime. At least. So, he sit down and, uh, the center on the Taiwanese team just dominated everything in the paint. And, uh, uh, they started winning even by more than ten points in, in the second quarter.

And they finished the halftime plus six or plus seven. So, our bet looked great. We took even plus point point, uh, plus five point five on, on the Taiwanese team. Because they were losing, uh, when we took it. So, everything looked great. Money line looked great. Uh, big odds, uh, plus five point five looked great. And then, you add to that this, the very strange movement before the game. And you would think, uh, you are, like, uh, in a very, very good situation.

And we were. Uh, they were playing good, uh, taking advantage of the fact that the other team doesn’t have, uh, a center in the paint. And, uh, just doing whatever they want there. Then, the third quarter came. And, uh, uh, the local coach, uh, rolled the dice and play, and, and played the American big man with four fouls.

And, uh, the game turned, uh, some stupid decisions by the Taiwanese team and, uh, they started losing. And, uh, then in the start of the fourth quarter, uh, the center on the Taiwanese team fall out. Even though the boxcorer had him with four fouls. Imagine betting just on the official stats.

And we lost. We lost by 8 in the end. They had 2-3 pointers in the last seconds and they they didn’t score them. And we lost plus one point point five also. Everything was lost. So, if you analyze what happened in this game prior to the game, the line movement that we saw, about four, five points, was, uh, crazy, was completely unjustified, because nothing has changed. There was no new information.

So, what it was, is somebody betting on the Taiwanese team, because of something we don’t know about. And my point is exactly. When somebody is betting there, you don’t have to react. There can be nothing. It’s just, it can just be an opinion. I can move lines everywhere in the world with my betting. If I take them on Pinnacle, I will move the lines everywhere. The whole world will copy from Pinnacle. And, uh, uh, if the max bet is not so big, and I am, like, very confident, and in that moment I have no other choice, uh, and closer to the start, I will do it.

I will have to do it. It doesn’t happen often, but, uh, my point is that, uh, it can be done. It’s not that hard. So, when you, uh, when you see a line movement, when you see the CLV much, much better than you took before, you think your bet is very good.

But, uh, my point is that, for me, it doesn’t really matter if it’s not backed by something I can see, I can touch, and I can analyze. And in this case it wasn’t. There was nothing. Completely nothing. It was nothing to such big extent that even though the Taiwanese team had so big advantage from the fourth, uh, second quarter on, they couldn’t, they still couldn’t win the game.

So, that whole line movement was, like, so, so very wrong. The whole CLV analysis would show, like, a great bet there, and, uh, but, uh, in reality, uh, there was nothing to back it. So, the, uh, what I and what you can take from all of this is that, uh, when you see the line movement, when you see the closing line, closing odds are much better than what you took, it doesn’t have to mean anything. It can, but it doesn’t have to be.

But then anything in life is either something or nothing. And the same thing here. So, why even bother looking in there? It can be a small indication that you need to dig deeper in that direction. I agree. Because there can be something. And maybe even in the most cases there is something.

But the main thing to remember is that doesn’t have to be. It can be just some guys betting, some groups or whatever. And, uh, from what I hear, it can happen in any league. It can happen in NBA. If some big player, by player, I mean, a betting person or a group of people, decides to bet a couple of millions onto there. Uh, a couple of millions is a figure I just made up, but, uh, you get my point.

So, if you are, if you are analyzing CLV, if you are looking at line movement, my advice, just do it very, very carefully. Because it doesn’t have to mean anything if there is nothing substantial that actually moves it.

It can be information. Or just an opinion.

If you haven’t started betting, don’t even start. If betting is already a problem, free and confidential help: BeGambleAware.

WHERE TO GO NEXT

Episode 8: The line moved. So what? →

Even the official stats can be wrong →

“It’s already priced in.” Is it? →

Previous: episode 15, Losing streaks →

Next: episode 19, Patience →

All JJ Podcast episodes →

Watch & listen: every video →